By david l wilson consumers are ultimately the ones responsible for dangerous conditions in garment assembly plants in the global south, hong kong-based business executive bruce rockowitz told the new york times recently. 8 arguments in support of sweatshop labor in talk to these families in the dumps [of phnom penh, cambodia], and a job in a sweatshop is a cherished dream, an escalator out of poverty, the. The virtues of sweatshops the poor of these less-developed countries would have fewer opportunities for work and would lose all the other benefits of foreign.
Sweatshops are typically associated with inhumane treatment of the working poor, and people without choice of work and labour conditions the general consensus of the global community is that sweatshops are unprincipled and unacceptable. David l wilson is co-author, with jane guskin, of the politics of immigration: questions and answers, monthly review press, july 2007 he also co-edits weekly news update on the americas, a summary of news from latin america and the caribbean. And this 2012 study from researchers at duke university found that sweatshop workers in el salvador believed that their factory jobs represented an improvement over their previous jobs in areas such as working conditions, job stability, location, benefits and schedule.
A refreshing look at the benefits of sweatshops this feature is not available right now please try again later. Sweatshop phase not so, says benjamin powell, a professor of economics and business at texas tech university who, controversially, argues that sweatshops are economically and socially beneficial to the countries they're in. Even if sweatshop labor is unfair, it's a bad idea to prohibit it taking away sweatshops just takes away an option for the poorest workers of the world while countries can make it illegal for sweatshops to pay low wages, they cannot prevent sweatshops from shutting down and paying no wages. It is important to analyze the benefits brought by sweatshops from a third world country or developing nation's point of view moreover, the general population affected by sweatshops is usually those who live in extreme conditions of poverty.
Sweatshops are awful places to work but they are often less awful than other jobs sweatshop workers could take and this is the basic argument in defence of sweatshops. Economic benefits of sweatshop labour essay sample sweatshops are typically associated with inhumane treatment of the working poor, and people without choice of work and labour conditions the general consensus of the global community is that sweatshops are unprincipled and unacceptable. The argument, voiced by outlets as diverse as slate and the spectator, is that the economic benefits of the sweatshop economy override concerns about the rights of factory workers.
My newest video at learnlibertyorg is up now, on sweatshops and the poor obviously, there are a lot of complexities that i wasn't able to go into in a 5 minute video i address some of those complexities in this blog post on the left-libertarian critique of sweatshops see also these other. Sweatshops are manufacturing workplaces which treat its workers inhumanely, paying low wages, imposing harsh and unsafe working conditions, demanding levels of performance that are harmful to the workers and child labour. Benefits of sweatshops sweatshops have received bad popularity in the past and even fighting against them has become a misguided and easy cause nevertheless, it is essential to realize that there are many benefits of working at sweatshops.
The benefit of sweatshops robert gelber integrative seminar 300 professor duclos alegue april 28th, 2011 abstract: many countries, industries and people are becoming more affected by sweatshops in different ways because of they're continuous increase in growth. A sweatshop, according to powell, is a workplace with low wages (compared to us standards), and poor, possibly unsafe, working conditions and benefits, again compared to us standards the sweatshops that powell is defending are those where people voluntarily choose to work. Nike has been accused of using sweatshops since the early 1970s, when it produced goods in south korea, the people's republic of china, and taiwanas these countries' economies developed, workers became more productive, wages rose, and many moved on to higher paying jobs.